Metcalf had more pins in 8 less matches then Ness last year.
EDIT: And Metcalf tends to pin more high level wrestlers then Ness does. This year he pinned Mueller, last year he pinned Ruschell, Bubba, and Heinrich Barnes (all All-Americans). Ness pinned jake Strayer last year (in terms of All-Americans) and his best pin this year is probably Ridge Kiley. He's awesome and great, but Metcalf is better.