Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: What Should Shane Carwin's Next Move Be?

  1. #1
    World Champ
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Minneapolis, MN

    Star What Should Shane Carwin's Next Move Be?

    With his title hopes currently on hold, Shane Carwin is currently in limbo.

    Carwin's last bout was a first round TKO victory over Gabriel Gonzaga in early March. Eight months have passed, and Carwin has yet to see the inside of the octagon again.

    Carwin was originally slated to take on fellow up-and-comer Cain Velasquez; that match was scrapped in favor of a shot at the UFC heavyweight champion Brock Lesnar.

    That match was set to headline UFC 106, but due to Lesnar's recent ill health, their bout has been put on hold.

    All these changes have left Carwin in a less than advantageous situation.

    First, Carwin has essentially lost his title shot, and second, the majority of top heavyweights in the UFC are set to take on other opponents.

    What's the next best move for Carwin?

    It has been reported that Gabriel Gonzaga has been forced to pull out of his UFC 108*bout with fast rising sensation Junior Dos Santos due to a staph infection in his elbow?a perfect opportunity for Carwin to step up and fill in on short notice.

    While it would not be a title shot, it would be an opportunity for Carwin to square off against another name opponent. Considering that Lesnar will likely be on the road to recovery for the next six months to a year, if he ever returns, Carwin needs to move on. The longer he is kept in this state of flux, the more time the rest of the division has an opportunity to overtake his position in the title picture.

    In a perfect world, the UFC would use the Velasquez-Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira bout and this potential Carwin-Dos Santos fight as a mini interim title tournament. Then once Lesnar is healthy and ready to return, the UFC could set up a title unification bout.

    The creation of an interim title would do two things for the UFC. First, it keeps the division relevant with fans while Lesnar is recovering. Second, it provides the UFC with a vehicle to keep the hungry contenders satisfied and gives them a chance to earn their spots on the ladder.

    A bout between Dos Santos and Carwin simply makes too much sense. The fans should want it because it is an interesting matchup. The UFC should want it because they need a solid co-main event for UFC 108.

  2. #2

    Default Re: What Should Shane Carwin's Next Move Be?

    Carwin won't be ready to fight by january due to his knee injruy and his wife is expecting a baby in february and could be a complicated one so he does not want to fight on feb either. He should fight dos santos or mir/kongo in march.

  3. #3
    National Finalist leglace's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Tampa Florida

    Default Re: What Should Shane Carwin's Next Move Be?

    I would like to see "jaws" Duffee get a shot at Dos Santos if Carwin isn't up to it. Let's be honest, Carwin was not quite that deserving of the title shot over Cain or Dos Santos. Carwin has one significant win over Gonzaga. Dos Santos one upped it with both Werdum and Mirko. Cain has both Rothwell and Kongo. Duffee needs a chance to show his stuff and prove he is among these 3 as prospects. At the moment there is not a single #1 contender. A tournament would make sense.
    I pictured you as that guy Gaylord in Showboat, passing up taxis to walk because he's broke and playing it off as if it's the doctor's advice. - Clmetal

  4. #4

    Default Re: What Should Shane Carwin's Next Move Be?

    Tournament, definitely. Carwin, Velasquez, Mir, Nogeira and whoever else is top ranked (I don't follow the UFC very closely). Winner gets the interm title, Brock Lesnar fights winner as soon as he is healthy.

  5. #5

    Default Re: What Should Shane Carwin's Next Move Be?

    Regardless of who he fought, he would have to do it on a card that is headlined by someone else. Not one heavyweight in the UFC could draw a main event stigma that Brock was going to and nobody really cares about Mir, Nog, Carwin and even with Velasquez new appeal-he isnot quite popular enough yet. They will have to all fight on the same card and create a minin tournament.
    My picks:
    Velasquez vs. Nog
    Carwin vs. winnner of Mir/Kongo
    Winners fight for the Belt-forget this interm crap. If the title holder can't fight (in Brocks case it is sad, but non the same) then they give up the belt and come back in high rankings to face the current champ. Don't have 2 belts for one weight class.

  6. #6

    Default Re: What Should Shane Carwin's Next Move Be?

    Works for me, so long as Brock gets a shot at the winner as soon as he gets healthy.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts