First of all, why do you only have two choices? There are many more wrestling shoes out there than two. Second of all, what does it really matter? If you're concerned about winning wrestling matches, then save the money and attend a camp. If you're just worried about looks, play basketball. Shoes do not determine the outcome of a match. All you need is good tread so they don't slide on the mat when driving for a takedown or half nelson.
Personally, I'd get some old school, crappy looking shoes and prove to everyone that the wrestler makes the shoe. Not the other way around.