That is not what I am looking for.
I thought of him immediately, but I didn't have much access to Iowa wrestling information while he was wrestling. So I only found out about his real performance after the fact. In the best year they had together, Ironside had bonus points in about 2/3 of his matches but the next year bonused in 28/33 matches. So those two are right up there. Williams I knew the least about of the three.
Metcalf is an interesting one - (if my internet homework is right....) sophomore year he won the Hodge, but he lost a match that year, so how massive a favorite was he coming in? The next year he lost in the final, but everyone has to see that might happen given he had lost to Caldwell before. His senior year he came in with a loss, (and had a tight final match) so again, how big a favorite was he to bonus his way through.
Borschel is another interesting one - solid Junior year, great senior year. But was he even the 1 seed with Lewnes in the same weight class?
So part of this is being an all-time level wrestler, the other is making sure you don't have another all-time wrestler in your weight class (Dake/Taylor kind of thing)