LoSt

Obviously it doesnt matter anymore at this point because he has a playoff spot locked up, but should wiltz really be allowed to start humphrey as a backup at 133 when the guy he drafted is wrestling 141 for ohio state?

It doesnt matter for playoffs but come confrences/ncaas it could make a difference

JensenS

The guy he drafted isn't their 141 starter. Jaggers is.

Wiltz

Enright was hurt for the first two and a half months and has wrestled 3 times. Twice at 141 once at 149. If you are trying to penalize me for drafting a guy that was out with a knee injury, it would have been nice to let me know. so I could have taken someone in the supplemental draft instead of a week before the play-offs.

Don't you need to clean your room or shovel the walk before your mom gets home?

__________________
"He quits, not because he wants to, but because he has to. He has no choice.
" -Tom Brands 01/20/08

LoSt

enright has wrestled at 141 for ohio in their last two duals

LoSt

*shrugs* Im just pointing out that thats not very consistent with the rules its jensens call not mine. If humphrey was enrights backup while he was injured and you got to draft him thats fine but now that he's obviously healthy and not wrestling where you drafted him anymore I dont see why you'd still be able to score humphrey.

Im not trying to be a dick Im just pointing out that following the rulebook you really shouldnt be allowed to score points there. I follow the rules just like everyone else.

I didnt put in harvards 133 backup last week because I wasnt sure who they'd wrestle and jensens said I needed to have a specific name and that cost me 6 points. If we're going to be strict about some of the injury rules why wouldnt we be strict with all of them?

LoSt

Also as to enrights injury it seems like its probably mostly his inability to make 133 as he's wrestled 141 and 149 this year and I think I recall him having trouble with weight last year.

JensenS

I'm letting him keep Humphrey.

Is the rule about replacing guys in your line up kind of screwy? I admit, that it definitely is. Clarifying that rule is one of my bigger priorities to look at with respect to the league this off season.

But I really think its unfair for me to jump in and snatch a guy Wiltz has been using due to injury for basically the whole year, especially when the rule has been kind of a gray area this year

Put yourself in his shoes dude, if you were in this situation with the rule murky like this, and I came and tried to take a guy away from you, you would blow your top.

Wiltz

I was told by some tOSU guys Enright had a bad knee at the beginning of the year and he would be out until the end of December. From there I don't know what is up with him.

__________________
"He quits, not because he wants to, but because he has to. He has no choice.
" -Tom Brands 01/20/08

Schlottke

As this has been solved, I'm locking the thread.

__________________
High School Wrestling Blogs Groups Videos
My Profile Wrestling Toolbar 2.02

LoSt

Well Schlottke decided to go and lock the thread before I finished my post...


it doesnt really matter to me since it doesnt look like Im going to make the playoffs but you definitely need to be more consistent with how you apply the injury/nonstarter rules. Enright obviously isnt injured anymore and you're still letting wiltz use a backup ohio guy at 133, I wasnt able to start preston because he wasnt elligible 1st semester and under the rules I thought that fell under the "shit happens" catagory where you're just out of luck.

If I'd been able to start harvards backup 133 as well as being able to start him last week it would have given me 18 points which is a definite improvement from the 0 preston has gotten me so far and might end up being the difference between getting a playoff spot or not.

ISU has had problems with Iowa states 125 pounder and has basically gotten screwed over because the guy he drafted didnt end up starting and he wasnt able to pick up the backup because there wasnt a known injury, then during the supplimental he dropped clark for kist and cael pulled the switcheroo on him and he hasnt been able to get points at 125 all year.

Whats the deal with saf/glasser? Didnt someone lose out there too?