* Need a HWT
* Can't keep Metcalf next year
* Good shot Caldwell makes it to the finals
* Do Metcalf's tournament points = Caldwell & a dinged Dudz?

* LY Metcalf scores 6 more tourney points than Caldwell when he took 5th.

I need a HWT cause Hammond placed 5th in EIWA with 4 automatic bids. Still an outside chance he gets an at large.

I would do it

I'm not in your league, but I wouldn't do it. But then, I'm a Metcalf homer.

to me the biggest thing is the keeper factor. If you could keep metcalf it wouldnt make a ton of sense to trade him, but you cant. Not only that, but I cant keep him either, so you'll still have a shot at drafting him next time around, and you wont be spotting me the #1 guy in the country for next year (which would have been nice).

Thats actually the reason I proposed the deal in the first place honestly... I was already looking ahead. Even without being able to keep him though I think it still makes my team stronger since I will still have a solid heavy.

What are you offering him gofer?

I wouldn't do it just because Caldwell's health is in question. He has been out for a month and hasn't wrestled anyone tough since coming back.

Originally Posted by Gold

I wouldn't do it just because Caldwell's health is in question. He has been out for a month and hasn't wrestled anyone tough since coming back.

Caldwell is not the one to worry about. He was out for like a week and a half and then came back and absolutely destroyed his bracket at accs. I watched him in the finals he looked great, just like he has all year with the exception of the one match where he got hurt.

Dudziak is the guy with questionable health, but he still managed to win ACCs.

Actually to be honest Metcalf is probably the only guy on all of the playoff teams that I would even consider trading Caldwell for, because he is the only one guy at 149 who I think will place higher then caldwell and has similar bonus potential.