Since we are looking at the other end of the spectrum, I thought I'd start one for the most objective fans.
Just for the heck of it, I'm going to pick someone from each of the teams with decent followings on the board.
Iowa: Vaisforlovers. Its no wonder he's not popular on the Iowa boards, he generally makes his picks based on sound logic, something that you don't see as often as you should on these boards. Its crazy to say this, but Herkey may almost be closer to making this list than he is the homer list.
Minnesota. JensenS. Goferphan has many moments of clarity too, but JensenS is more consistent.
Ohio St. No clear frontrunner for me, I'll let you guys sort it out.
Penn St. Since I can't vote for myself (that wouldn't be very objective) I'll give it to TomWright25 or Bluebloodlion. Both show respect to the opponents and have it in them to criticize a Penn St wrestler when needed.
Feel free to add your picks, and to nominate fans from other teams!