It would be a completely different match today given how much McDonough has improved, but of course Oliver has improved a great deal as well. He was excellent as a freshman and somehow looked significantly more dominant last year. Oliver also beat McDonough in a freestyle match after their redshirt year at FILA Juniors 6-0,fall and then pinned Andrew Long in the finals. If he's not struggling with weight, Oliver is the best wrestler in the country IMO. Taylor scores more because of his motor and turns from top, but he's not as solid against elite opponents, at least I haven't seen that from him yet to put him above Oliver.