Darrion "Metcalf-Slayer" Caldwell
Bubba "Take THAT, Cael" Jenkins
I think Caldwell was the better wrestler overall, but last years results force me to vote for Jenkins, there is no comparison between going out on top or ending your season with an injury default.
I don't even know how much of a case could really be made for DC at this point other than his head to head win over Bubba.
To avoid criticism say nothing, do nothing, be nothing.
Is Caldwell still competing?
Add a world team or Olympic team to his resume and I'll take Caldwell.